Blog Post

Keep the Noise Down! 

Sophie Maycock - ORCA Communications Team • 14 December 2020

KEEP THE NOISE DOWN!

Sophie A. Maycock | 14th of December 2020.


In recent years scientists have become increasingly concerned that the impact that human beings have on the natural world might be more extensive and insidious than previously thought. We have seen how litter, plastic pollution and oil spills can have rapid impacts on marine life, and we are starting to understand that climate change could seriously affect our oceans in the long-term… but there is also another form of disturbance that scientists are becoming aware of; “noise pollution”. Noise pollution refers to the plethora of sounds which are pumped into marine environments by human activity. You might think this does not sound like a serious issue, but, in fact, when you consider underwater drilling, shipping lanes, sonar, the use of explosives, seismic surveys, blast fishing… you start to realise that we expose marine life to an enormous amount of unnatural sound (known as “anthropogenic sound”). There has been a lot of attention on this issue in recent years, after several mass stranding of whales and dolphins were linked to noise pollution. But what about other animals? Is noise pollution really damaging to fish like sharks?

Noise pollution can be seriously damaging to many different species of marine wildlife. At the lowest level, extensive background noise from boat motors or offshore wind farms, even at relatively low volumes, can cause increased stress to marine life or mask their sounds which are critical for their survival. Research has shown that noise pollution alters the behaviour of bony fish; changing how they feed, socialise, avoid predators and move around their habitat.

Louder noises, such as those from underwater explosions, can even cause temporary or permanent deafness. In the case of “cetaceans” (whales, dolphins and porpoise) it is thought that noise pollution can be especially damaging because these animals use sound to communicate, navigate and hunt prey, like fish and squid. We now know that anthropogenic sound can alter how often whales vocalise, the patterns of their movement and how they forage for food. There is an increasing body of scientific literature about how noise pollution affects cetaceans (Bravo, scientists!), but work on other animals, like sharks, is more scarce (Chapuis et al , 2018).

 

It might surprise you to learn that sharks can hear! But it’s true. In fact, they have a very well-developed sense of hearing and are able to detect sounds from several kilometres away. Some species of sharks even use sound to communicate; using “tail slaps” on the surface of the water to compete for food resources.

 

The bodies of sharks are equal in density to the surrounding water. Therefore, sound waves travel throughout their entire body, until they come into contact with a structure which is more or less dense. This is known as being “acoustically transparent”. In sharks, the sound waves coming into contact with a dense organ known as the “otoconia”, causes delicate sensory cells (known as “cilia”) to be moved, which is interpreted by the brain as sound detection (Casper et al , 2012). It is thought that sharks can perceive sounds with a frequency between 20 Hz and 1.5 kHz, depending on the species. They are especially sensitive to low-frequency sounds, with a peak in perception between 200 and 600 Hz (Casper et al, 2012 & Chapuis et al, 2018).

 

 

To understand how noise pollution might affect sharks, a research team baited sharks towards their boat and tested how they behaved when they played them different sounds through an underwater microphone. They compared the reaction to artificial sounds of mixed frequencies and intensities, against the calls of orca ( Orcinus orca ), which are experienced naturally in the marine environment. In Western Australia, they tested seven different species: sicklefin lemon sharks ( Negaprion acutidens ), bronze whalers ( Carcharhinus brachyurus ), grey reef sharks ( C. amblyrhynchos ), dusky sharks ( C. obscurus ), sandbar sharks ( C. plumbeus ), scalloped hammerheads ( Sphyrna lewini ) and zebra sharks ( Stegostoma fasciatum ), and they additionally tested great white sharks ( Carcharodon carcharias ) with the same experimental set-up in South Africa (Chapuis et al, 2018). The Australian species were all coastal and/or reef dwelling, whereas great whites are nomadic and wide-ranging.

 

The scientists discovered that all the coastal sharks approached the bait much less often when both different sounds were played to them, compared to “control” conditions (when no sounds were played). They recorded significantly fewer inquisitive interactions when sounds were being played and the sharks did not make attempts to bite the bait. Whats more, when playing the artificial sounds, the sharks were much slower to arrive at the food source. The great whites also arrived late and left quickly when artificial sounds were being played. Basically, despite being tempted in with tasty baits, the sharks were still deterred by unnatural noises. These findings confirm that underwater sounds do alter shark behaviour across many different species, but that the responses can vary between species (Chapuis et al, 2018).

But what does this mean?

 

 “Certain underwater sounds can alter the behaviour of some sharks and potentially deter them from entering an area and/or interacting with a potential food source”- Capuis et al, 2018

 

 

In the natural environment, continuous rhythmic sounds, like wind, waves, bubbles, the flow of schooling fish and the calls of other animals fall within the low-frequency range perceptible to sharks. These sounds are a part of their natural “soundscape” and so do not elicit a startle response. However, anthropogenic sounds are often chaotic and lacking rhythm, with quick variations in intensity and frequency. The researchers hypothesised that these unfamiliar sounds likely acted as a “cue”, which triggered sharks to exhibit “aversion behaviours”. This tells us that anthropogenic noise might repel sharks from food-rich habitats. In the long-run, this could shift their natural ranges and seriously impact upon their health (Chapuis et al, 2018).

 

 

Realistically, anthropogenic noise pollution is not going to stop any time soon - international shipping, drilling for oil and military exercises are all seriously big business. Therefore, the only weapon that we have to fight it will be to perform more scientific research into the effects of noise pollution. If we are able to determine that specific anthropogenic sounds adversely affect marine life, then we can petition parliaments to control these activities in some way.

 

 

 “Given the combination of the worldwide increase in anthropogenic aquatic noise as well as the drastic population decline in many species of sharks, it is imperative that studies be conducted to determine whether these fishes are being further threatened by our noise pollution” - Casper et al, 2012

 

 

If you would like to learn more about how noise pollution is affecting marine life and how you might be able to help, visit our website and become a member to support our Smart Whale Sounds Project!

 

References

 

Casper BM, Halvorsen MB & Popper AN ( 2012 ) . Are sharks even bothered by a noisy environment? Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology , 730.

 

Chapuis L, Collin SP, Yopak KE, McCauley RD, Kempster RM, Ryan LA, Schmidt C, Kerr CC, Gennari E, Egeberg CA & Hart NS

 

( 2018 ). The effect of underwater sounds on shark behaviour. Scientific Reports , 9:6924.

 



ABOUT THE AUTHOR: 


Sophie A. Maycock BSc(Hons) MSc EEA is a member of ORCA's Science Communication Team, writing interesting articles for us on the latest shark science. Sophie also recently set up her own website for science communication called Sophie's Shark Speak, where you can read more of her "Fin-tastic" articles.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

by ORCA SciComm Team 5 September 2022
Bird Flu is a serious threat to Irish Gannet Colonies. ORCA SCI-COMM TEAM | 04 September 2022 ORCA Ireland are deeply concerned about the severe epidemic of bird flu of the H5N1 strain, which is highly pathogenic in cases of pelagic seabirds and has now hit seabirds in Irish waters. According to top scientists at the University College Cork (UCC), avian influenza has now reached Irish Gannet colonies. Recent reports from Irish scientists and members of the public have indicated a huge increase in the numbers of dead northern gannets off the Irish coasts. These increases in seabird deaths may be linked to the Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (H5N1).
by ORCA SciComm Team 14 July 2022
PCB Pollution Threatens Global Killer whale ( Orcinus orca ) Populations. ORCA SciComm Team | 14th July 2022 Global killer whale population are predicted to collapse due to pollution with polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). A scientific report which used individual-based models combined with globally available data on PCB concentrations found that PCB-mediated effects on reproduction and immune function threaten the longterm viability of >50% of the world’s killer whale populations.
by ORCA SciComm Team 29 April 2022
Russian Navy Trained Dolphins Deployed in Crimea ORCA SciComm Team | 29th April 2022 Russian Navy Trained Dolphins may have been deployed in Crimea, with two sea pens having been spotted at one of their bases in satellite imagery since the start of the Ukraine invasion in February, according to the US Naval Institute.
by Danielle Brennan | Communications Officer 15 March 2022
FEMALE KILLER WHALES FACE GREATER IMPACT FROM NOISE POLLUTION Danielle Brennan | Communications Officer | 15th March 2022
by ORCA SciComm Team 1 March 2022
A solitary common dolphin can speak porpoise language! ORCA SciComm Team | 1st of March 2022 A new paper published in “ Bioacoustics - The International Journal of animal sound and its Recording ” has detailed how a solitary common dolphin in Scotland has learned to speak porpoise language!
by ORCA SciComm Team 4 February 2022
Iceland to end whaling in 2024 with drop in demand for whale meat. ORCA SciComm Team | 4th February 2022 Iceland have announced an end to commercial whale hunts in 2024, after a government minister commented there was "little justification for the practice". Whaling in Iceland is no longer profitable, due to a decrease in the consumption of whale meat and since Japan re-commenced whaling operations after a three decade hiatus in 2019.
by ORCA SciComm Team 25 January 2022
RUSSIAN MILITARY TESTS THREATEN WHALES IN IRISH WATERS ORCA SciComm Team | 25th of January 2022
by ORCA SciComm Team 11 December 2021
Shell Oil & Gas Seismic Surveys Threaten Whales off South Africa ORCA SCI-COMM TEAM | 11th of December 2021 Across the globe there is public outrage due to the planned seismic surveys to search for oil and gas deposits off South Africa's Wild Coast by energy company Shell. Environmental NGO's, Human Rights Organisations and local fishing communities are trying to stop the seismic surveys through litigation, due to the harmful impact seismic surveys can have on marine wildlife. South Africa is home to 37 species of whales and dolphins, but these anthropogenic activities threaten the survival of wild whales off Africa's south coast. Let's dive deeper to investigate what seismic surveys are and how they can harm whales!
by ORCA SciComm Team 9 December 2021
How to Create a Sustainable Wardrobe! ORCA SciComm Team - 9th December '21 The idea of creating a sustainable or ethical wardrobe from scratch is, without a doubt a challenging task. You may not be able to wear the brands you are used to, limiting your choices in terms of trends, not to mention having to spend a little more than you would normally. All of these are valid concerns, but creating a sustainable wardrobe isn't as hard as you may think. Read on to find out tips and tricks to help you transition from a "fast fashion" foe to a "slow fashion" soul sista!
by ORCA SciComm Team 4 December 2021
Russian “Whale Jail” finally Abolished. ORCA SciComm Team | 3rd of December 2021 The incommodious confined pens in Russia’s infamous “Whale Jail” have finally been abolished to ensure marine mammals will not be held in these captive facilities in the future!
Show More
Share by: